Will Baby be Witch or Warlock?–Revisited

2 Mar 2013:

While continuing my research into accused witches in New England, I discovered additional resources1. It appears that Mrs. Rachel Fuller, wife of John Fuller of Hampton, CT, may replace Lydia “witch” Gilbert (still looking for maiden name confirmation that she might have been a Lathrop), on my list of possible ancestors who were accused of sorcery and witchcraft in New England. Once again, the research continues, and I follow the paths redrawn for me by this additional resource. However, I remain compelled to correct and/or redact earlier writings as new information becomes available. I would never want inaccuracy or incomplete stories left untold because I didn’t take time to update my work.


The following blog, the first of at least two, looks at Witches and Witchcraft during the 15th Century–a period most commonly known as The Salem Witchcraft Trials. The second blog planned will focus on our family’s very own Lydia “witch” Lathrop Gilbert.

I lifted the article below directly from The Tuscaloosa News – Sunday, August 15, 1993, written by: Jane Alexander of The Associated Press, to frame the history around the topic and to show that witches and witchcraft continue to be of interest and concern today.

EDITOR’S NOTE: The descendants of the accused witches in Salem, Mass., 300 years ago include three former presidents and such disparate people as Clara Barton, Walt Disney, and Joan Kennedy. Now comes along a couple that only recently found out that their unborn child belongs in that company.

NEW YORK–I’m going to have my first child any day now. Girl or boy? My husband and I haven’t tried to find out. We’re more concerned about which ancestors the baby might take after. Will the child be curious or quiet? Tall or short? Witch or warlock?

Well, we’re not really concerned to tell the truth, but I will admit that I was astonished to discover that not long ago 300-year-old witch skeletons hung–literally–from my husband’s family tree.

Family Tree of Edward William Knight

Family Tree of Edward William Knight

Unbeknown to him and the rest of his immediate family, his ninth great grandmother, Sarah Towne Bridges Cloyce, and her two sisters, were accused of witchcraft in 1692 in Salem, Mass. Although Sarah escaped the noose, her sisters, Rebecca and Mary, were hanged.

Sarah’s name was buried in the family records as Sarah Towne, who married Edmund Bridges, Jr. in 1660. But after Edmund’s death in 1680, she married the widower Peter Cloyce. Only when reading accounts of the trials during last year’s tricentennial did it dawn on me that Sarah Cloyce, accused witch, was the same woman as Sarah Towne Bridges, esteemed ancestor.

Ed’s line of descendancy from Sarah is contained in the family history, “The Paddock Heritage,” which was self-published by some of his relatives in 1985.

Story lost

It’s not surprising that Sarah’s story was lost. Only in 1957 did the General Court of Massachusetts resolve “that no disgrace nor cause for disgrace” be borne by descendants of witch-trial victims.

Over the centuries, many families have indeed felt disgrace and distress.

New England author Enders Robinson calls the witch trials “the grimmest of stories and one in which my father believed plunged the family into ignominy, and was best “forgotten.” His sixth great grandfather, Samuel Wardwell, was hanged from a locust tree the same day as Ed’s Aunt, Mary Towne Estey.

Presidents, too

Three presidents–Taft, Ford, and Arthur–also are descended from one of Salem’s 20 executed witches or their siblings. So are Clara Barton, Walt Disney and Joan Kennedy. And, of course, our descendant in-the-making.

During the Salem hysteria, being related to an accused witch, was enough to cast doubt on one’s own innocence. Ed’s Sarah was likely singled out because her older sister had been accused.

So were they witches? No. The Towne sisters were devout Puritans. Then why were they accused? Theories range from the simplistic–boredom–to the bizarre–hallucinations brought on by eating moldy bread. The truth is likely more complex: a combination of family rivalries, fights over property, and grabs for power.

Rebecca Towne Nurse and Mary Estey were among 13 women, six men, and two dogs hanged as witches. Another 80-year-old man, Giles Corey, was tortured under a pile of stones as townspeople tried to force him to enter a plea. His only answer before being crushed to death was immortalized in Arthur Miller’s play, The Crucible. “More weight,” he said. Eight more accused witches died in jail.

Must confess

Only those who did not confess to witchcraft were considered dangerous. Those who admitted to guilt were not treated as harshly, particularly if they conjure up names of other “witches.” Those who refused to say they consorted with the evil were imprisoned, usually in irons, often tortured, and sometimes executed.

“They lost their lives because they commited the error of truth,” said Enders Robinson, author of “The Devil Discovered: Salem Witchcraft 1692.”

Rebecca, Mary, and Sarah were daughters of English-born William and Joanna Blessing-Towne. They moved their family to the settlement with the hopeful name of Salem, from the Hebrew word for peace.

It was there nearly 50 years later that their daughters would be tested.

“What sin has God found me unrepented of, that he could lay such an afflicition on me in my old age?” asked Rebecca. The 70-year-old matriarch was nearly deaf, was taken from her sickbed on March 24, 1692, and arrested for witchcraft.

Kids tormented

Local children said her “specter” tormented them. She was condemned, brought in chains into the First Church in Salem and–most horrific to the God fearing woman she was–excommunicated by unanimous vote. Rebecca was hanged on Gallows Hill on July 19, 1692.

Meanwhile, Mary and Sarah also had been jailed. Mary would not enter a false confession. “I dare not belie my own soul.” Mary was hanged, along with seven others, on a cold and rainy Thursday, September 22.

Sarah was spared. Though kept in irons for nearly a year, she fought back against her accusers. Upon hearing testimony of John Indian, one of the minister’s servants that she was a witch, she snapped in court: “Oh! you are a grievous liar.”

Eventually the political winds shifted, Sarah was freed on January 23, 1693, and spent 10 years before her death trying to clear her sisters’ names. A movie version of her battle, “Three Sovereigns for Sarah,” stars Vanessa Redgrave.

Today, Towne descendants have a 442-member family association. It features a quarterly newsletter, “About Towne;” coffee mugs; “Remember Rebecca” T-shirts; annual reunions, and the determination not to let history be forgotten.

Some descendants of witch-trial players would rather it be forgotten. The fact that Magistrate John Hathorne wore the robes of chief witch hunter haunted his great-great grandson, who altered his own last name to distance himself. In his essay “The Custom-House,” Nathaniel Hawthorne wrote of his ancestors: “I, as their representative, hereby take shame on myself for their sakes, and pray that any curse incurred by them may now and henceforth be removed.”

Five of the 20 who were executed had no known children or grandchildren. They leave only a legacy of refusing to betray their beliefs. I hope our child were inherit that, along with a drop of Sarah’s blood and bear Towne proudly as a middle name.–End of Article.

1Samuel Gardner Drake, Annals of Witchcraft in New England (Boston:W. Elliott Woodward, 1869), pgs. 150-156.

10 thoughts on “Will Baby be Witch or Warlock?–Revisited

  1. I’ve been exploring for a little bit for any high-quality articles or weblog posts on this kind of house . Exploring in Yahoo I finally stumbled upon this website. Studying this information So i am glad to convey that I have a very just right uncanny feeling I discovered just what I needed. I so much definitely will make sure to don’t put out of your mind this site and give it a glance on a constant basis.


  2. I am glad for commenting to make you understand of the great discovery my child experienced going through your webblog. She came to find a good number of things, with the inclusion of what it is like to have a wonderful helping style to let men and women clearly learn chosen very confusing topics. You undoubtedly surpassed our desires. Thank you for rendering those effective, safe, edifying not to mention fun guidance on the topic to Sandra.


    • Your comments about your child’s discoveries and experience are fuel for my soul. This is exactly why I write, hoping younger generations will learn and enjoy information that comes from generations who came before. Thank you.


  3. I have been browsing online more than three hours today, yet I never found any interesting article like yours. It is pretty worth enough for me. In my view, if all webmasters and bloggers made good content as you did, the web will be a lot more useful than ever before.


  4. I recently met someone that called me out on my ability to see things before the happen or read minds. As well as moving things around before bad things had to protect a loved ones or myself . he as well and my mother a someone else I met tonight that could pick on it. Im guess Im searching for answers, Im not sure to think about it. Plz help me with some input.



    • I believe I have a form of extra sensory perception, that is I anticipate things that often happen. And, I can be thinking about someone I haven’t seen or heard from in awhile and they will call, write, or just show up. All of thus seems more than coincidence, but I believe in Jesus Christ and only Him. Maybe we’re just more atuned to the energies that surround us than others?


  5. I think everything said was very logical. However, what
    about this? what if you added a little information?
    I mean, I don’t want to tell you how to run your blog, but what if you added a title that makes people desire more? I mean Will Baby be Witch or Warlock? | Our Heritage: 12th Century & Beyond is kinda boring. You might look at Yahoo’s front page and note how they create
    news headlines to get viewers interested. You might
    add a video or a pic or two to grab people interested about everything’ve written. In my opinion, it might bring your blog a little livelier.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s